
So, who's watching Hoarders on A & E?
I know a woman who's friend was a hoarder, and when she passed away in her own bed, her husband didn't know she was dead--for 2 days! So bad was her home, that the paramedics couldn't use a gurney, but had to shimmy her out in a sheet.
Another man I know does plumbing repairs and has frequented the apartment of a woman who saves and stacks used Kleenex. She carefully piles the crumpled tissue into columns, and has created noxious walls.
These are not urban legends. These are real stories, of real people, who, for whatever reason can't make the trip to the trash can. But according to the show's psychologists, Hoarders are mentally ill.
But are they really?
I'm a skeptic.
Nowadays, every "habit" has an illness attached to it. Alcoholics and drug addicts have a disease, but when I was a child, they were drunks and addicts. People aren't just fat or skinny anymore, they have an eating disorder. Homeless are no longer bums. Gamblers aren't irresponsible. So, it goes to follow that if you can't keep your house in order, it's not your fault, you have an illness.
To be certain some of the people portrayed seem to be mentally challenged, especially one woman who wore diapers and couldn't get through her house in a wheelchair, so she piled the soiled ones in piles that ate through her flooring. This particular show resonated elder abuse, not hording.
By labeling irresponsibility, we take the blame away. It's not your fault. You can't help it. But in the case of hording trash, I just can't believe it's an illness.
There's no reference in the Bible to hoarding, but it does give us instructions on "clean." The NIV lists 170 references! Even though the saying "Cleanliness is next to Godlessness" isn't in the Bible, it's still relevant to God's instructions.
The Bible talks about clean animals (Genesis 7:2 NIRV), clean hands (Job 9:30 NIRV), clean teeth, (Song of Solomon 4:2 NIRV) and a clean house (Matthew 12:44 NIRV), to name just a few.
The hoarders are coveting garbage, in a sense, making their junk their idols, and the professionals are coming in to validate they're mentally ill, rather than being truthful: "You're lazy, both mentally and physically." There are illnesses that preclude self-care, but most of us can take out the trash.
These hoarders never learned to keep house. It seems generational. If they grew up in filth, then they're comfortable.
We must take care of what we have before we take on bigger challenges, and that starts with just looking around the living room.
What do you think? Illness or laziness?
"If a man is lazy, the rafters sag; if his hands are idle, the house leaks." - Ecclesiastes 10:18
I know a woman who's friend was a hoarder, and when she passed away in her own bed, her husband didn't know she was dead--for 2 days! So bad was her home, that the paramedics couldn't use a gurney, but had to shimmy her out in a sheet.
Another man I know does plumbing repairs and has frequented the apartment of a woman who saves and stacks used Kleenex. She carefully piles the crumpled tissue into columns, and has created noxious walls.
These are not urban legends. These are real stories, of real people, who, for whatever reason can't make the trip to the trash can. But according to the show's psychologists, Hoarders are mentally ill.
But are they really?
I'm a skeptic.
Is this Trash or what?
To be certain some of the people portrayed seem to be mentally challenged, especially one woman who wore diapers and couldn't get through her house in a wheelchair, so she piled the soiled ones in piles that ate through her flooring. This particular show resonated elder abuse, not hording.
By labeling irresponsibility, we take the blame away. It's not your fault. You can't help it. But in the case of hording trash, I just can't believe it's an illness.
There's no reference in the Bible to hoarding, but it does give us instructions on "clean." The NIV lists 170 references! Even though the saying "Cleanliness is next to Godlessness" isn't in the Bible, it's still relevant to God's instructions.
The Bible talks about clean animals (Genesis 7:2 NIRV), clean hands (Job 9:30 NIRV), clean teeth, (Song of Solomon 4:2 NIRV) and a clean house (Matthew 12:44 NIRV), to name just a few.
The hoarders are coveting garbage, in a sense, making their junk their idols, and the professionals are coming in to validate they're mentally ill, rather than being truthful: "You're lazy, both mentally and physically." There are illnesses that preclude self-care, but most of us can take out the trash.
These hoarders never learned to keep house. It seems generational. If they grew up in filth, then they're comfortable.
We must take care of what we have before we take on bigger challenges, and that starts with just looking around the living room.
What do you think? Illness or laziness?
"If a man is lazy, the rafters sag; if his hands are idle, the house leaks." - Ecclesiastes 10:18


